Baffled by the Hyper-Sanitary
November 7, 2020
JOHN HARRIS writes at his blog:
As practically idiotic as any program must be that aims to ensure the “health of the collective”, I’m infinitely more disturbed by the moral assumptions—the immoral presumption, I should say—behind collectivist hygiene. The very idea that my society has the right to make me impede my airflow out of consideration for others is the most maniacally self-centered inversion of selflessness imaginable. I exist. You exist. Each of us poses certain potential threats to all others around us through the mere fact of our existence. We might misstep on an escalator with dozens of people below us. We might swipe an incautious pedestrian starting across an intersection while we’re peering at street signs. We might drop something that creates a sudden racket in the presence of a cardiac patient. Human life is a constant stream of such risks.
I’m not threatening your existence because I choose to have an existence. If I choose to sing, I’m not a threat to your life because I open my mouth and expel air. If I choose to sit at a table and eat a meal, I’m not a threat to your life because the juices circulating on my teeth may be ejected invisibly and borne away by the wind. If I hug a child who may go to the same kindergarten as yours, I’m not a threat to your life because an infection may be passed along from me the next school day that could eventually terminate you.
All such considerations are a selfish paranoia of unimaginable proportions. The spiritual sickness oozing from these equations is almost as baffling to me as it is disgusting.