[Here is the right version of this site.]
FOR NINE months, Monika Schaefer, a peaceful, nature-loving Canadian violinist from Alberta, has been in prison in Germany.
Her crime? Making this video. She has done nothing else. She has not called for harm or retribution toward anyone. The very idea that this mild-mannered woman who volunteers to play violin in nursing homes and schools would promote hatred or violence is patently ridiculous. And for this she is in the hands of the world’s most powerful bullies and is portrayed in the Canadian media with dehumanizing rhetoric as a dark, Hitleresque figure. That such a powerless person as this middle-class artist should be arrested and held in a foreign country strongly suggests that what she said is true. As Theodore Fontane, a 19th century German author, said:
The reason people are silenced is not because they lie, but because they tell the truth. When people lie, their own words can be used against them. When they tell the truth, there is no other countermeasure except violence.
Seized in January when she was visiting family in Germany and attending the trial of a lawyer who has defended other activists (thousands of people have been imprisoned or fined in Germany for thought crimes), Schaefer is accused of inciting “hatred.” The clever thing about accusations of hatred is that they can never be conclusively disproven. Hatred is invisible. It lies within the human heart. You can never prove you don’t have it. A society that possesses the vestiges of a Christian sensibility honors charity, making this word an extremely effective weapon. Invert these claims of hatred. In reality, it is those who promote lies about World War II (for financial or political gain) who should be in prison. Read it all in a mirror.
Imagine calling the police and saying, “I’ve just been robbed!!” — and then being thrown in prison by the police for being robbed. The twisted logic of imprisoning those with Monika’s claims is similar. Monika’s brother, Alfred, is also in prison for his Internet videos. Their ongoing trial is a journey into the absurd with the basic principles of international law overturned. Whatever the outcome, they will be crushed.
But please don’t think this is just about the Holocaust. It is not.
That subject is an effective filter for identifying those who are most capable of resistance, those who possess so much honor and integrity that they will risk intense social ostracism and even imprisonment or death to question received wisdom with facts and logic. Honor and integrity are more dangerous than guns.
Schaefer’s imprisonment is ultimately about thought itself — and individuality. We should not be advocates in response of mindless, undiscriminating “free speech.” Only the truth deserves to be disseminated. It is no accident that a powerless, middle class artist is involved. The artist is often the first person to cry out. Beautiful music — Schaefer has obviously devoted herself to beautiful music — instills a love of truth. If she were a musical celebrity, she would have all kinds of interests to protect. But she is not. The middle class has less at stake and it must be crushed intellectually and psychologically because of its natural instincts against tyranny, as the kulaks were crushed under Communism. It is precisely because Schaefer is reasonable, courteous, kind, gentle and non-threatening that she is especially dangerous. The people who are responsible for her imprisonment in Germany, we can surmise, are deeply afraid of these qualities and their inherent persuasive power. They must envy these qualities. We are living in the pages of a dystopian novel. Legions of conservative writers quote George Orwell — but say nothing about a living example of his bleak warnings. Feminists predictably say nothing about outrageous abuse of a woman. Read More »