Our Lady of La Salette
WHENEVER I read of Westerners converting to Islam, I am not particularly surprised. These conversions are the result of proximity to Muslims, but also, I believe, of the fact that Muslims hold to one very important truth that is stubbornly rejected by many Western believers. Muslims believe, or at least act as if they believe, that only one religion is true. In this, they are absolutely correct. Either one religion is true — and all other religions are false — or no religion is true. Muslims believe the former proposition.
In Islam, some Western secularists sense the clear and refreshing air of a certain honesty. They know, without perhaps being able to articulate it, that the ecumenical, “interfaith” movement that has swept the modern West is nonsense. Astute non-believers understandably have contempt for this opiate of the masses. Different religions hold to different propositions, even if they agree on some points. Both sides of a contradiction cannot be true. This is obvious even to a child.
Those who believe that all religions are partly true are sloppy thinkers or dangerous liars. “Interfaith-ism” is far more damaging than atheism. Most people are not inclined to atheism. Most people, indeed all people, are inclined to wanting God on their own terms.
Many so-called Catholics believe, for instance, that other religions are partly true and that Catholicism is fully true. This cannot logically be so. Either Catholicism is the one true faith, and other faiths are entirely false [as religions], or Catholicism is wholly false. The Catholic Church states that salvation can only be attained through the Church. But Lutherans implicitly believe that salvation can only be attained through the Lutheran Church. They just don’t state it openly.
Here is a good analysis from the website Novus Ordo Watch. For non-Catholic readers, simply replace whatever their own religion is with the reference to Catholicism to arrive at the basic philosophical conclusion that only one religion is true or none are true: Read More »