Government as Santa Claus
April 14, 2023
ALAN writes:
And when the Congress put their hands, not into their own pockets, but into the National Treasury, for the purpose of bestowing alms on a selected portion of our citizens, it may be well to pause and recall the description given by [Guglielmo] Ferrero, the noted modern historian of ancient Rome, of some of the causes which led to the fall of that proud and prosperous Empire:
‘Little by little, the State let itself be persuaded to do for each of its cities what it had done for Rome…. With a view to easing the misery of the urban proletariat, it took public works in hand in every direction, regardless of their utility. It distributed victuals free or at half-price….
‘But all these schemes cost money…. The intensification of the evil was met by an increase in the dose of the very remedy which aggravated it…. Matters went from worse to worse, until the system reached the limit of its elasticity, and the whole social fabric collapsed in a colossal catastrophe. This is precisely the mistake which modern civilization must learn to avoid….’
It is dangerous folly to teach people to regard Government as something which exists to pay their bills. What we, each of us, need today is a good stiff dose of robust, local, self-reliance. Self-help breeds self-respect….
— American legal scholar Charles Warren, Congress as Santa Claus [Charlottesville, Virginia, The Michie Company, 1932], pp. 144-46
Do those words not apply precisely to the gargantuan Welfare State that Americans who work for a living agree to support for the benefit of those who don’t work and don’t want to? Read More »