THERE IS far too much to comment upon in the public ruminations on Mother’s Day. Suffice to say, if you thought Mother’s Day was a time to actually celebrate sacrifice rather than pushy entitlement, you were wrong.
Even the supposedly conservative Phyllis Chesler, in a paean to motherhood, makes the ridiculous assertion that if only British poet Ted Hughes had been a good wife to Sylvia Plath, and tenderly served her every need, the doomed poetess might not have killed herself. For Chesler, Mother’s Day is an appropriate time to reflect on how self-sacrifice has made women unhappy. The narcissism of contemporary women observes no holidays. If veterans exhibited the same whininess on Veterans Day, we would have to retire our armed forces for good.
Stephanie Coontz in The New York Times writes:
One of the most enduring myths about feminism is that 50 years ago women who stayed home full time with their children enjoyed higher social status and more satisfying lives than they do today. All this changed, the story goes, when Betty Friedan published her 1963 best seller, “The Feminine Mystique,” which denigrated stay-at-home mothers. Ever since, their standing in society has steadily diminished.
She then goes on to prove that mothers who stayed home in the fifties must have enjoyed higher status. Nothing else could explain why they would do something so demeaning. Housewives of the fifties, Coontz argues, were overworked, depressed and physically assaulted by their husbands. Thanks to feminism, the lives of homemakers are better. They are only depressed today.
Coontz fails to mention that there are relatively few full-time homemakers left. Feminism has not just destroyed the status of homemaking, it’s virtually eliminated the homemaker herself. Read More »