
“THE faithful are asking about the future of the Holy Mass. The new liturgy has begun in several churches, on a trial basis, and the general impression is not pleasant; it feels strange. It is possible that, after some time, the faithful will become accustomed to it and find the new rite familiar. But this is not about customs, tastes, or impressions. It is about giving expression to dogma.
[…]
“It is not surprising that thousands upon thousands of priests have addressed the Holy Father asking him to preserve the rite and liturgy of St. Pius V, along with the new rubrics for the Holy Mass. There is widespread anxiety, to the point that many prelates advise us “not to fear” that the Holy Father will intervene—and does intervene—constantly in the issues raised at the Roman Synod, etc. What we sincerely desire is that he intervene decisively in both liturgy and doctrine, before it is too late.
[….]
“The Liturgy of the Holy Mass of Pope Saint Pius V has educated generations and has engendered habits for the exercise of virtues, always indispensable but, above all, in times of general capitulation.
“I have read the ‘Novus Ordo’ and I notice that the concept of UNITY has overflowed the liturgical sphere to the point that a ‘brother’ of Taizé, Max Thurian, has stated that with the ‘Novus Ordo,’ non-Catholics will be able to celebrate the Eucharist with the same prayers as Catholics. But the first priority is not unity, but doctrine. To maintain unity, one cannot capitulate or compromise on doctrine, even if only partially and not entirely essential, but at least approaching it. This is not the way to attract our ‘separated brethren.’ When the Protestant Reformation repudiated the dogma of the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist, it effectively killed Catholic symbolism; because if the church is not the house of Jesus, it can be a museum of artistic curiosities where truth and life are absent.
“The Council of Trent opposed the full force of Tradition and the full force of its authority to the cold Protestantism that attempted to erase the Eucharistic liturgical symbolism. In other words, in drafting the Novus Ordo, wasn’t too much consideration given to pleasing the Protestants? The assessment of the “brother” from Taizé gives us pause.” [bold and strikethrough added]
Fr. Miguel Oltra, OFM
NEW FORCE Magazine, No. 143, October 4, 1969
See full letter here. [Translated from Spanish by Google]