A Career Woman Against Feminism
July 14, 2023
JEANETTE Leonard Gilder (1849-1916) was a successful author and journalist who worked for the Chicago Tribune, Boston Saturday Evening Gazette, Boston Transcript, Philadelphia Record and Press, and other newspapers.
She was one of many thousands of women opposed to the women’s franchise in the late 19th century, a founder of the Massachusetts Association Opposed to the Extension of Suffrage to Women.
Gilder argued that suffragists were utopians. Instead of a paradise on earth, they would, she argued, unleash “the wheels of purgatory.” The intensely religious zeal and impossibly bright hopes of a perfect future she believed women would bring to politics is all too familiar to us today.
An excerpt from her essay, “Why I am Opposed to Woman Suffrage:”
IT has been quite a shock to people who do not know me, but who thought they did, to find me opposed to woman’s suffrage. Because I have been for so many years a working woman, and because the profession I chose is, or was at the time I entered it, supposed to be entirely a man’s profession, they thought I wanted all the privileges of men. But I don’t. You could have counted the women journalists on the fingers of one hand at the time I entered the ranks. Nowadays you could not find fingers enough in a regiment to count them on. There are now certain branches of journalistic work that are almost entirely given over to women, and women not only edit mere departments of daily papers, but there are those who edit the Sunday editions of some of the biggest dailies.
I am a great believer in the mental equality of the sexes, but I deny the physical equality. Read More »