SAM writes:

I wanted to comment on your post “Are All Religions ‘True?'” because it is something I have been thinking about a lot recently. I regularly interact with white liberals of the “spiritual, but not religious” variety and they all tend to think that the major religions are interchangeable and equal.

Not only is this view incoherent, it displays a breathtaking hubris which masquerades as humility. It is incoherent because it violates logic at the most rudimentary level: it maintains that contradictory propositions can be true simultaneously. The liberal refuses to face up to fact that either Jesus is God incarnate or he isn’t; either Muhammad is God’s prophet or he isn’t; either the soul will face divine judgment after death or it won’t; either the extirpation of all desire is highest goal of spiritual enlightenment or it isn’t. The liberal refuses to face this because, once these stark alternatives are seriously acknowledged, one is put into the uncomfortable position of having to make an existential choice where the possibility of error is real and the consequences of error are of the utmost gravity. (more…)

WHENEVER I read of Westerners converting to Islam, I am not particularly surprised. These conversions are the result of proximity to Muslims, but also, I believe, of the fact that Muslims hold to one very important truth that is stubbornly rejected by many Western believers. Muslims believe, or at least act as if they believe, that only one religion is true. In this, they are absolutely correct. Either one religion is true — and all other religions are false — or no religion is true. Muslims believe the former proposition.

In Islam, some Western secularists sense the clear and refreshing air of a certain honesty. They know, without perhaps being able to articulate it, that the ecumenical, “interfaith” movement that has swept the modern West is nonsense. Astute non-believers understandably have contempt for this opiate of the masses. Different religions hold to different propositions, even if they agree on some points. Both sides of a contradiction cannot be true. This is obvious even to a child.

Those who believe that all religions are partly true are sloppy thinkers or dangerous liars. “Interfaith-ism” is far more damaging than atheism. Most people are not inclined to atheism. Most people, indeed all people, are inclined to wanting God on their own terms.

Many so-called Catholics believe, for instance, that other religions are partly true and that Catholicism is fully true. This cannot logically be so. Either Catholicism is the one true faith, and other faiths are entirely false [as religions], or Catholicism is wholly false. The Catholic Church states that salvation can only be attained through the Church. But Lutherans implicitly believe that salvation can only be attained through the Lutheran Church. They just don’t state it openly.

Here is a good analysis from the website Novus Ordo Watch. For non-Catholic readers, simply replace whatever their own religion is with the reference to Catholicism to arrive at the basic philosophical conclusion that only one religion is true or none are true: (more…)

  TEXANNE writes: Unfortunately, this is the same level of thinking one encounters among most adults.

C.S. writes:

I would like to express my great gratitude for your site, The Thinking Housewife, and the educated commentary it provides. It is difficult as a college freshman to find a decent appreciation of the effects of the revolution on society. I applaud you for standing against both the revolutionaries on left and right, and most especially, for avoiding confusion with the so-called ‘Men’s Rights Movement,’ which is, by the rejection of duty, in forfeiture of manliness.

(more…)

IT WAS Steve Sailer who once said that homosexuals don’t really want marriage, they want weddings. The homosexual wedding is, aside from being a fun party, the most visible way of normalizing homosexuality. Homosexuals have never shown a tendency to spend their lives with one person; quite the opposite, many homosexuals don’t spend a week or a single night with one person. Two West Point graduates “married” at the West Point Chapel Saturday, another milestone in the implosion of the American military.

Meanwhile, Retired Army Maj. Gen. Patrick Brady, and a few other prominent retired military, told World Net Daily that the homosexualizaton of the military and the push to place women in combat have demoralized service members and seriously compromised their willingness to fight. How could these not be demoralizing forces? Normal male aggression has been criminalized. Liberals make no secret of despising the military. They believe the military is to blame for warfare in the same way they believe guns are to blame for homicide. One of their most effective tactics has been to recruit women and pansies to kill off the male hero. In the end, that’s what the military sexual assault tribunals, which will become ever more Stalinist as the years go by, are about: eradicating the fighting man on an inner level, making him constrain his own aggressive impulses for fear of reprisal. In the end, this has nothing to do with women who want to fight or men who want to marry men.

(more…)

AMENDMENT 66, the Colorado education bill that was the darling of the liberal establishment and would have raised an additional billion dollars in taxes for all-day kindergarten and other programs, was defeated yesterday by almost two to one. See the Denver Post’s story here. This is significant given that out-of-state proponents of the bill, including Bill Gates and Michael Bloomberg, and the teacher’s union spent millions of dollars promoting the measure, seriously outspending the opposition.

Speaking of education in Colorado, a bill was passed this summer that requires sex education to begin in kindergarten. It takes a lot of money to promote sexual decadence.

(more…)

CHIRLANE McCRAY and her husband, the newly-elected mayor, Bill de Blasio, are the perfect first couple for New York. He is white and she is black. That fact alone could not help but make their ratings soar. She’s a former lesbian and he’s from a broken home. Very good on both counts. He considers socialist Latin America his ideal society and she seethes with anger when describing her childhood in a largely white community. It’s all almost too perfect to be true. De Blasio beamed over his mixed-race family as he campaigned and, like Obama, appealed to envy of the rich in portraying New York as a “tale of two cities,” the oppressed and the oppressors. He won in a landslide yesterday.

McCray, who does not take her husband’s name, had this to say in a recent interview about the future of the city:

The city needs to become, in terms of opportunities, more like what it used to be. Now I know, people say, oh, the crime, the blah, blah. You know. That’s — we are never going to go back to those days. We don’t want to go back to those days. That’s not even an issue. What we want is for people to feel like they can raise their families here. That their kids can go to college. They can do better themselves. There is a route into the middle class. We want young people to feel like they can come here.

(more…)

NADIA BOLZ-WEBER, the author of a bestseller and the “pastrix” of a Lutheran church in Denver, is the subject of a profile in The Washington Post. Here’s a condensed version. After trying to make it as a stand-up comedienne, Bolz-Weber redirected her ambition (times are tough in the stand-up business) and got a theology degree of some kind in a seminary. She became a Lutheran minister, which fortunately involves being on stage and talking a lot about oneself too. Her “passion” and “life-changing fervor” are inspiring even white suburbanites, whom she reluctantly forgives for permitting her little opportunity to demonstrate her inclusiveness and for having committed the mortal sin of being not so cool. Her book is modestly titled: Pastrix: The Cranky, Beautiful Faith of a Sinner and Saint.

She’s on a plane nearly every week to headline church leadership gatherings because of the way she articulates the place of the religious liberal in America. Next up is Calvary Baptist Church in Washington’s Chinatown, where she will speak to an overflow crowd of more than 600 people Tuesday evening.

Her message: Forget what you’ve been told about the golden rule — God doesn’t love you more if you do good things, or if you believe certain things. God, she argues, offers you grace regardless of who you are or what you do.

Christianity, Bolz-Weber preaches, has nothing to do with rules; it is the process of things constantly dying and then being made new. Those things, she says, might be the alcoholic who emerges into sobriety, some false narrative we have about ourselves, religious institutions that no longer inspire.

This woman must be reading Pope Francis. Not surprisingly, Bolz-Weber does not think fondly of her “fundamentalist” Protestant upbringing and she calls most liberal churches “the Elks Club with the Eucharist.” On that point, she is clever and correct. The Elks Club with the Eucharist leads here to Saturday Night Live with the Eucharist. It’s all part of the pseudo-religious, pseudo-moral atmosphere of modern Protestantism. (more…)

  DANIEL S. writes: Three people in Norway are dead after being stabbed to death by a Sudanese man who hijacked a bus after being ordered deported. The man was later arrested. As far as the murder suspect is concerned, his identity and religious affiliation have not been released. He is reportedly from South Sudan, thus making it possible that he was from either a Christian or animist background, though it is all very possible he was Muslim. Either way, such a man should have never been in Norway. It is furthermore curious as to why this man was allowed to walk around freely after having been ordered deported. Once again a Western nation's policy of multiculturalism and mass Third World immigration results in deadly consequences. (And, once again, such a story will quickly be buried and forgotten.)

THANK GOODNESS, the overblown, increasingly pagan and macabre celebration of Halloween is over for another year. Here is a recent post from the blog Eponymous Flower about an Italian bishop who condemned Halloween. It would be nice if there were more voices against it. Bishop Massimo Camisasca issued a statement that said:

“Halloween is a mixture of heathenism and commercialism that is rejected in both components equally.”

(more…)

VOTERS in Colorado are being asked this week to approve a measure that would raise an additional $1 billion for schools, fund all-day kindergarten throughout the state and provide more programs for immigrants who can’t speak English. Given that the voters who stand to pay the most are in the minority, the measure is unlikely to fail. Residents with incomes above $75,000 will pay 5.9 percent in state income taxes, up from 4.6 percent.

As Aristotle said, democracy is a form of organized theft. And to Americans, any amount of thievery is justified to support schools, which are considered magical equalizers. Strangely enough, the inequalities do not disappear, but that does not reduce the widespread faith.

In many parts of the country, it is extremely difficult for a family to survive on one income. Taxes are a big reason why this is so. The state funds all-day kindergarten by defunding homes.

(more…)

NEXT YEAR, the order of religious sisters known as the Daughters of Charity will permanently sever their ties with St. Thomas Hospital in Nashville, an institution which they opened more than 100 years ago. At Tradition in Action, Marian T. Horvat describes how the liberalism of Vatican II effaced the religious order and gradually transformed the Catholic hospital, once under the capable management of women who took vows of lifelong poverty and charity, into a modern secular institution run by bureaucrats. Dr. Horvat writes:

The competence, energy and expertise of the nursing Daughters of Charity made them much in demand. But it was something more that won them the love and devotion of the people they served. In their distinctive grey habit with the white cornette, these sisters embodied lives of sacrifice. They received no personal salaries, they renounced the social amenities and feminine vanities of the world – all with the aim of serving Christ and seeing Him in the suffering sick of humanity. Such a noble mission reflected in the demeanor and person of each sister, who became a symbol of the model selfless nurse.

After Vatican II, however, things started to change. No more triangular white cornettes were seen in the hospital halls. The Sisters now were in modified habits or secular dress. Soon, the vocations started to diminish and the School of Nursing closed. (more…)

IN THE recent entry on one couple’s home birthing photos, a nurse says she was appalled by the degree to which the health of the baby was endangered to take pretty pictures of the half-naked mother in a kiddie pool. By the way, this is somewhat impolite to ask, but how does one empty a swimming pool filled with water, blood, and other bodily substances in one’s living room? There were no photos to explain.

(more…)

BUSINESS INSIDER has an excerpt from a how-to book on divorce by Laura Wasser. In the book, Wasser describes a “divorce” by a lesbian couple who had conceived children with a sperm donor, one woman contributing the egg in each case and the other the womb. Interestingly, the judge in the divorce case (homosexual couples break up at a much higher rate than heterosexual ones so divorce courts should be busier than ever) could not conceal his utter amazement. He was apparently new to the decadent world of lesbian reproduction. (more…)

KARL D. writes:

A man who was lost in the Canadian wilderness for three months had to kill and consume his dog to stay alive. He was finally found barely alive and is now in critical condition. I came across this article about him in the The Daily Mail and have been disgusted by what I read in the comments section. The anti-human sentiment and lack of critical reasoning is breathtaking. Comment after comment is filled with “I would rather starve to death than kill my dog,” “What a horrible selfish man,” “He should have just let himself die,” and one even said, “If I found out my father killed one of my dogs to stay alive I would never speak to him again.” I can’t even begin to wrap my head around this. (more…)

JANE S. writes:

Tanishq, a leading jewelry brand in India, has produced a TV commercial that is stirring up controversy.

It shows a beautiful bride preparing for her marriage ceremony. In Hindu society, jewelry plays a massively important role in weddings, engagements, and every other celebratory event in a woman’s life.

Then an adorable little girl appears on the scene and it becomes apparent that she is the daughter of the bride. This is a second marriage for the woman. (more…)

. TODAY, on All Saints Day, the Church commemorates the saints in heaven, all of them, those who are known to us and those who lived in obscurity. As we rejoice in them, the saints bow down from eternity and say, "Come, join us." In The Holy Souls: Vive Padre Pio, Fr. Alessio Parente, O.F.M. Cap. writes of a humorous comment Padre Pio, the venerated Italian priest, made about his own reputed saintliness: Padre Pio certainly did maintain a childlike simplicity and did not try to conform with the world's idea of what a saint should be. On one occasion some sugar-coated almonds (confetti) were being passed around the refectory. A little while later, Padre Pio, still with one in his mouth, was on his way to hear Confessions of the men in the old sacristy. When he reached the door, he prevented his confrérès from opening it, saying, "Wait! Let me finish this candy. Otherwise people will say: 'What kind of saint is this? He even eats sweets!' "  

ALAN writes:

The recent incident involving “youths” who beat a man for honking at them may be added to the long list of savage crimes by blacks that Lawrence Auster chronicled in many posts at View From the Right.

Here is yet another example that may have escaped your attention, and it involves precisely the kind of savagery that Mr. Auster discussed at VFR: (more…)